|
UNDERSTANDING VARIABLE PITCH
ADVANTAGES
What is a variable pitch
wind turbine?
A
variable pitch turbine is one in which the rotor blade pitch angle is
continuously adjusted by an internal hub mechanism to provide constant
speed output over a wide range of wind speeds. It is a precision
solution to overspeed control. [See the ‘Variable Pitch’ curve
in the graph below]
Variable pitch wind turbines can start very efficiently in
low speed winds, typically found around more populated areas. Upon
starting to move, the rotor blades adjust in pitch, enabling the turbine to
reach operating speed quicker than fixed pitch blades. Upon reaching the
controlled operating speed they continue to adjust and produce power at constant
output speed, right up to and including very high wind speeds, regardless of
wind speed or electrical load. There is no need to avoid operating in high
winds. And, significantly, because constant operating speed is readily reached
at lower speed winds, the need for high and costly towers is much
reduced.
What is a fixed
pitch wind
turbine?
A fixed
pitch turbine is one in which the turbine rotor blades operate at a fixed
pitch angle. They are usually designed for peak performance around 28
mph on a typical operating curve (see the smaller ‘Fixed Pitch’ curve in the
graph above).
Above
that point (peak output), over-speed control is required for safety reasons. So,
although power output is good at peak output, fixed pitch turbines are then
forced to limit over-speed operation by aerodynamic blade stall,
or furling (swinging out of the wind), or electronic
braking, or combinations of these. [Additionally, there is a natural
tendency to erect high and expensive towers for these turbines in order to
achieve the high rated speed more of the time.]
Why is over-speed control
so important for fixed pitch wind turbines?
If
turbine blades rotate too fast, they are subject to high stress levels from
centrifugal, bending, torsion, and flapping forces which can ultimately result
in dangerous failure. Hence the need for over-speed control in any wind
turbine.
Is over-speed control
effective in fixed pitch wind turbines?
Over-speed control in fixed pitch turbines is always a challenge, and it
comes at a price. Since their blades lack pitch adjustment, fixed pitch turbines
must employ stall, furling, or electronic braking methods to
achieve over-speed control. These are adequate solutions, but they also
give up on virtually all the energy contained in winds above
the design speed and a significant amount of energy in
winds below it.
Are there additional
drawbacks to using fixed pitch angle?
Yes. A
less obvious drawback of fixed pitch operation is that you cannot optimize rotor
blade pitch angle for both startup and high speed
winds. For example, assume you have a 10 degree fixed pitch blade
angle. The turbine blades will start turning in a low speed wind. But, at
higher wind speeds, with blades now cutting into the oncoming wind at
tip speeds up to 6 or so times that of the oncoming wind speed (for good
airfoils), the pitch angle requirement diminishes (because of the
change in relative wind vector). Now, a fixed pitch angle of only 2 degrees
would be much more suitable. That suggests two different settings. This is
simply not possible with fixed pitch blades.
Thus,
the choice of a single fixed pitch angle forces either
good startup and early stall or poor startup and good high
speed performance. Either choice translates into a performance compromise,
compared to variable pitch blades which adjust to perform well in both
cases.
Does fixed pitch operation
have a place?
Yes, if
sustained wind speeds happen to be close to a typical fixed pitch
design speed of ~ 28 mph, fixed pitch performs well. At these speeds, startup
concerns are irrelevant. However such special locations are not that plentiful,
as local wind maps will show.
Which design has the
fundamental advantage?
By
definition, a variable pitch wind turbine is more effective over a
much larger range of wind speeds, including low speed, which it excels at.
Further noting that lower speed winds prevail most of the time in more populated
areas, the variable pitch turbine advantage clearly prevails as the logical
design choice.
UNDERSTANDING AIRFOILS
Do airfoils
matter?
Yes,
blade airfoils profoundly affect wind turbine performance, particularly for
small wind turbines.
Because
aerodynamic performance deteriorates at small scale due to low Reynolds Number
effects, small airfoil performance is even more critically dependent on
good aerodynamic design. Drag forces for a high performance airfoil can
approach a hundredth of the lift force. Our blades (design by Dr. M. Selig,
University of Illinois) are in that category.
Achieving and utilizing high blade lift is the only way of
extracting good performance out of a small wind turbine.
THE PERMANENT MAGNET ALTERNATOR
Does the stator winding
have a large effect on Wind Turbine performance?
Given
the correct choice of rotor magnet, the stator winding is
absolutely critical in obtaining maximum turbine generator (permanent magnet
alternator) performance at sustained operating speed. A stator winding of the
correct wire size, lamination performance, number of turns, and heat dissipation
characteristics will deliver the maximum output voltage and current, reliably,
for a given rotor magnet field strength. The proper interplay of blade
aerodynamic forces, electromagnetic forces, and heat transfer, in terms of
generator loading, speed, and output, is like a ballet. When everything is
properly orchestrated, performance is
outstanding.
| |
Variable pitch
operation illustrated |
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
Fig. 1 |
|
|
Each
curve illustrated above in Fig.1 represents a blade operating at a
fixed pitch angle (see legend). Consider the red curve A as a fixed pitch angle design
choice.
As wind speed (and Tip-Speed-Ratio, l) increase, the coefficient of power (Cp), moves up along the
curve A following the red arrow
. As the
wind speed continues to increase, however, Cp peaks at the design wind speed and
then starts to decrease again as it continues to move to the right, back down
the curve. Stall and loss of efficiency ensue for that particular fixed ( 6 deg)
blade angle choice .
In contrast, green curve B demonstrates
the benefit of operating a blade with variable pitch blade angle. In this case, as the
blade angle changes with increasing wind speed, Cp forms a continuous curve B,
basically formed by following Cp max in a smooth continuum, from each fixed
angle curve peak, to the next, to the next, etc. as wind speed increases. Note
also that, at higher wind speeds, Cp exceeds that obtainable by a fixed pitch
turbine blade set at 6 deg. (curve A). Simply, the variable pitch blade can
easily adjust, as in this example, to a 2 deg. angle setting, a major advantage
not possible with the fixed 6 deg. setting of curve A.
Thus it is clear
that a fixed pitch angle can either be set for
easy startup, which compromises high speed efficiency, or for high speed
efficiency which compromises startup. You can’t have both.

|